These are two items of information that don't fit with what we know of Andrew Odron.
This is a passenger list that has a 37 year old Andrejz Odron from Galicia departing from Bremen and arriving in New York on November 2 1909. He leaves behind a wife Kath Odron and is headed to Pennsylvania.
This is from a 1915 Chicago City Directory. There is a Andrew Odron with an occupation as Baker at 2623 Luther.